A paper presented at the yale center for faith and culture consultation on gods power and human flourishing, sponsored by the mcdonald agape foundation i the inclination of the philosopher, when confronted with a topic such as gods power and human flourishing, is to resist the temptation to plunge straight ahead to discuss the topic. Rights and wrongs, presents an account of justice in terms of inherent human rights. Nicholas wolterstorffs cheap shots wesley hill first. Here are some issues youll want to consider when gathering data for your discourse analysis. Publishing outstanding work on the structures and strategies of written and spoken discourse, special attention is given to crossdisciplinary studies of text and talk in linguistics, anthropology, ethnomethodology, cognitive and social psychology, communication studies and law. Divine discourse comprises nicholas wolterstorff s philosophical reflections on the claim that god speaks. This claim figures large in the canonical texts and traditions of judaism, christianity, and islam, but there has been remarkably little philosophical reflection on it, in good measure so professor wolterstorff argues because philosophers have mistakenly. He returned to yale in 1989, where he was a member of the divinity school, the philosophy department, and the religious studies. In the first part of the book, the authors discuss the development of discourse analysis as a research method and identify the main theoretical elements. Wolterstorff argues that at least some of us are entitled to believe that god has spoken. Volume 57, 2020 vol 56, 2019 vol 55, 2018 vol 54, 2017 vol. A critique of wolterstorffs theory of the bible as divine discourse maarten wisse 1 international journal for philosophy of religion volume 52, pages 159 173 2002 cite this article. Philosophical reflections on the claim that god speaks by nicholas wolterstorff isbn. N icholas wolterstorffs recent case for samesex marriage, delivered as a lecture at neland avenue christian reformed church in grand rapids in midoctober, bears many of the virtues weve come to count on from the yale professor emeritus of philosophical theology.
Discourse markers have been described as serving to establish coherence between text pieces, to address functions of information structure, and to elaborate on or modify the text see, e. Like many are the scholars who make it their professional occupation. Toward a christian aesthetic eerdmans, 1987 nicholas wolterstorff. Wolterstorffs fear is that severing the commanded love of scripture. As the noah porter professor emeritus of philosophical theology at yale university and senior fellow at the institute for advanced studies in culture at the university of virginia, he has been a leading christian philosophical voice both in the academy and the church. Journal of discoursesvolume 6 wikisource, the free online. The book combines this story with deep and clear thinking, centered in the biblical revelation, about how christians should think about justice. Philosophical reflections on the claim that god speaks,1 nicholas wolterstorff sets out to explore this claim. Divine discourse addresses the traditional theme of divine revelation in a disarmingly direct way, by reflecting philosophically on the meaning of recurring biblical phrases, such as thus sayeth the lord and of liturgical utterances, such as this is the word of the lord. Jul 21, 2016 as opposed to singlevoiced discourse where a topic is expressed in a straightforward way, speakers who practice doublevoicing speak with a dual agenda.
Wolterstorff considers and rejects the idea that all the events generative of divine discourse were contained in gods precreation plan p. Pdf representing logical and semantic structure of. Nicholas wolterstorff is one of the great thinkers of our time. In a very thoughtprovoking conversation with nicholas wolterstorff on the nature of christian scholarship, alvin plantinga voices a concern that christians in disciplines other than philosophy are too buffaloed by the whole academic establishment of the discipline in question, and there is a premium on fitting in and conformity with the way things are done. This claim figures large in the canonical texts and traditions of judaism, christianity, and islam, but there has been remarkably little philosophical reflection on it, in good measure so professor wolterstorff argues because philosophers have mistakenly assimilated divine.
This claim figures large in the canonical texts and traditions of judaism, christianity, and islam, but there has been remarkably little philosophical reflection on it, in good measure so professor wolterstorff argues because philosophers have mistakenly assimilated divine speech to. Philosophical reflections on the claim that god speaks by wolterstorff, nicholas isbn. While we may not often speak of this term, some of our everyday actions would fall under its very definition. The way wolterstorff deals with this question reminds me of a discussion between him and henk hart years ago in philosophia reformata 1979, 1981. Sep 20, 2014 character and being of godcreationsalvation of the dead the unpardonable sinresurrectionbaptism of the spirit, etc. Interpretation of discourse connectives is probabilistic. Yhwhs rule over israel, as we analysed it earlier, was founded on his acts of salvation and judgment and on his gift of an inheritance. Abstract this paper examines demonstrative pronouns used as deictics to refer to the interpretation of one or more clauses. Nicholas wolterstorff quotes author of lament for a son. In this book, based on his 1993 wilde lectures at oxford, wolterstorff brings together themes from speech act theory, biblical interpretation, religious epistemology, theology and philosophical hermeneutics. Philosophical reflections on the claim that god speaks nicholas wolterstorff. Fill out the form below and receive your selected paper now. Justification, legitimization and naturalization of mergers. Reason within the bounds of religion eerdmans, 1988 nicholas wolterstorff.
Like most of professor wolterstorff s books, it is a first word rather than a final word on a thought provoking topic. Journal of discoursesvolume 23 wikisource, the free. Jan 30, 2009 a discussion of oliver odonovans the desire of the nations volume 54 issue 1 nicholas wolterstorff skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Structure and ostension in the interpretation of discourse deixis bonnie lynn webber department of computer and information science university of pennsylvania philadelphia pa 191046389. Wolterstorff, 9780801048456, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. A 5 page paper which provides a summary overview and critical evaluation of nicholas wolterstorffs 1987 book, lament for a son. Like many are the scholars who make it their professional occupation to occupy themselves in this towering edifice of culture, exploring its nook and crannies, developing their responses, making their contributions here and there, and helping to. Summary and evaluation of the book lament for a son by nicholas wolterstorff.
What is doublevoiced discourse and how does it affect us at. Wolterstorff, as a result, does not feel bound by the tenets of traditional theism in developing his liturgical theology, and says explicitly that the doctrine of the divine simplicity should be discarded p. Liturgy, justice, church, and world eerdmans, 2011 nicholas wolterstorff. Character and being of godcreationsalvation of the dead the unpardonable sinresurrectionbaptism of the spirit, etc. Wolterstorff on divine commands part 1 glenn peoples introduction nicholas wolterstorff, in his masterful work justice. Wolterstorff is the phenomenon of domination disguising itself as love. Faith is a footbridge that you dont know will hold you up over the. Philosophical reflections on the claim that god speaks nicholas wolterstorff the canonical texts and traditions of judaism, christianity, and islam claim that god speaks, but philosophers usually mistakenly treat such speech as revelation. Nicholas wolterstorffs cheap shots wesley hill first things. Our approach uses a recursive neural network and a newly proposed attention mechanism to compute a representation of the text that focuses on salient content, from the perspective of both rst and the task. Publishing outstanding work on the structures and strategies of written and spoken discourse, special attention is given to crossdisciplinary studies of text and talk in linguistics, anthropology, ethnomethodology, cognitive and social psychology, communication studies and.
A critique of wolterstorffs theory of the bible as divine discourse. Wolterstorff takes the findings in current speechact theory and applies them to the claim that god speaks. After reading it once, you may want to read through again, either doing a backwards outline of the article writing the. Gods power and human flourishing nicholas wolterstorff a paper presented at the yale center for faith and culture consultation on gods power and human flourishing, sponsored by the mcdonald agape foundation i the inclination of the philosopher, when confronted with a topic such as gods power. Drawing on critical discourse analysis on three fairclough, 1997, we concentrate historically significant finnish cases.
He insists that his project is not another treatment on theological revelation, but that discourse is different from revelation. In divine discourse, wolterstorff takes up three important philosophical topics, viz. What is doublevoiced discourse and how does it affect us. Nicholas wolterstorff and the practice of christian scholarship but very little by him. Calling christians to be true to gods shalom in all dimensions of life, philosopher nicholas wolterstorff brings the religious vision of the reformation to bear on such urgent matters as world poverty, nationalism, urban ugliness, and the tragedy of liturgy in protestantism. Divine discourse 9780521475570 by nicholas wolterstorff. To understand the speech patterns one need to be clear about the term discourse and text. We show that discourse structure, as defined by rhetorical structure theory and provided by an existing discourse parser, benefits text categorization. Nicholas wolterstorff quotes 7 wallpapers quotefancy. Nicholas wolterstorff argues that contemporary speechaction theory, when appropriately expanded, offers us a fascinating way of interpreting.
Representing logical and semantic structure of knowledge acquired from discourse1 article pdf available in cognitive psychology 73. What is doublevoiced discourse and how does it affect us at the workplace. Justice in love eerdmans, 2011 nicholas wolterstorff. Regardless of whether one agrees with the content of. I found this book to be stimulating in some of its analysis, and wolterstorffs farranging acumen is evident in these. Filled pauses as markers of discourse structure marc swerts centrum voor nederlandse taal en spraak, universitaire lnstelling antwerpen uia, universiteitsplein 1, b2610 wilrijk, belgium and ipo, center for research and usersystem interaction, p. Youll want to read through the article at least once before beginning to answer these questions. Wolterstorff s divine discourse, it is clear that it is a groundbreak ing and philosophically powerful piece. As a 22yearold, i held a stray job fetching bundles of fur from minks, seals, polar foxes, blue foxes, and red foxes to show the buyers at oslo fur auctions. It begins a conversation and encourages further discussion. Nicholas wolterstorff institute for advanced studies in culture. In divine discourse nicholas wolterstorff defends the coherence and.
Wolterstorff reports one particularly vivid example of this phenomenon drawn from his experience of the effects of apartheid in south africa in 1976. Nicholas wolterstorff choice is always performed against a background of habit. This book will be a major contribution to a philosophical and. Journal of discoursesvolume 6 wikisource, the free. Undertaking discourse analysis for social research ebook by. Philosophical reflections on the claim that god speaks 9780521475570. Employing speech act theory as an exegetical tool on the. Undertaking discourse analysis for social research ebook. This claim figures large in the canonical texts and.
Nicholas wolterstorffs journey toward justice is far more than his personal story of how his encounters with suffering people shaped his thinking and life around an active concern for justice. Doublevoiced discourse is a phrase coined by the russian philosopher and linguistic theorist named mikhail bakhtin. He returned to yale in 1989, where he was a member of the divinity school, the philosophy department, and the religious studies department. He has managed, in fact, to combine a major fear of computationalism. He says the events generative of divine discourse cannot all be the consequence of gods implementation of a plan formed at creationit is highly likely. Neumann offer a concise, accessible introduction to discourse analysis in the social sciences. Philosophical reflections on the claim that god speaks 1995. Wolterstorff on love and justice an augustinian response joseph clair abstract in justice in love, nicholas wolterstorff argues for a unique ethical orien tation called careagapism.
Nicholas wolterstorff explains the difference between analytic and continental philosophy and how each approaches the topic of christian humanism. Divine discourse comprises nicholas wolterstorffs philosophical reflections on the claim that god speaks. Wolterstorff also suggests that there are times when god, in appropriating the human discourse, will not only do with the text what the human author did, but he will also do something different. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Nicholas wolterstorff on analytic and continental philosophy. Reason within the bounds of religion eerdmans, 1988. Structure and ostension in the interpretation of discourse.
Like most of professor wolterstorffs books, it is a first word rather than a final word on a thought provoking topic. He says the events generative of divine discourse cannot all be the consequence of gods implementation of a plan formed at. Justification, legitimization and naturalization of. Journey toward justice is not only a fine primer in the basics of christian political thought, it is an inspiring testimony about what it means to seek the shalom that god intends for the creation, narrated in firsthand encounters with the realities of human suffering. After teaching philosophy for two years at yale, he returned to the philosophy department at his alma mater in 1959.
There a book about him on being a christian in the academy. Discourse, put simply, is structured collections of. Keskos acquisition of tuko 1996 in the finnish retail sector. Philosophers have never before, in any sustained fashion, reflected on these matters, mainly because they have mistakenly treated speech as revelation. This book presents a theoretical reflection about how god communicates to human beings. Wolterstorff on divine commands part 1 right reason. The value of enhancing students critical awareness of. The nonfoundational epistemology of nicholas wolterstorff. Customers who bought this item also bought these digital items. Divine discourse myrrh the moore institutional repository. All journal articles featured in discourse processes vol 55 issue 1. A critique of wolterstorff s theory of the bible as divine discourse.
512 1405 776 850 986 483 977 780 1494 473 290 636 589 1424 1489 1185 1289 1163 411 425 250 730 860 1014 1239 1328 1331 187 76 69 748 395 363